Pakistan renews push for new provinces as political parties weigh constitutional and political implications
By Islamuddin Sajid
ISLAMABAD - Pakistan has renewed efforts to build political consensus on the creation of new provinces, opening a fresh debate over the country's administrative structure, provincial autonomy and the distribution of political power as the government seeks support from major political parties for possible changes.
The debate has gained momentum following statements by senior government ministers, consultations among political leaders and discussions involving President Asif Ali Zardari, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and leaders of opposition parties.
Defence Minister Khawaja Asif has said that political consensus on new provinces is being developed and that disagreements could be resolved within weeks. He expressed hope that a new administrative arrangement could emerge in the coming year, describing the creation of additional administrative units as a positive development for Pakistan.
Speaking to Geo News, Asif said all political parties were being taken on board and that the issue had not been raised at the direction of the military establishment. He said he had personally supported an effective local government system and administrative reforms for several years.
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has also discussed the possibility of creating new administrative units and suggested seeking public opinion through a referendum.
The proposals have triggered debate over whether Pakistan should establish additional provinces to improve governance, bring government closer to citizens and address longstanding demands for better administrative representation.
- Political consensus remains the biggest challenge
The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) and other political parties have different political and constitutional considerations regarding the proposed changes.
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif is reportedly supportive of creating new provinces, according to senior journalist Hamid Mir, although he faces reservations within his own party, particularly from former prime minister Nawaz Sharif and Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz.
Mir has suggested that Shehbaz Sharif's position on the issue has not been publicly articulated as strongly as that of some members of his cabinet.
The prime minister faces the challenge of securing agreement within the PML-N leadership while maintaining its governing partnership with the PPP, whose support would be important for any constitutional amendment.
President Zardari and Shehbaz Sharif discussed the issue during a meeting in Lahore on November 14. According to media reports, the discussions included the constitutional process for creating new provinces and the possibility of taking public opinion into account.
Zardari is considered a key figure in the negotiations because the PPP's position on the territorial integrity of Sindh could determine whether a broader political agreement is possible.
- PPP supports administrative debate but opposes division of Sindh
The PPP has historically opposed dividing Sindh and maintains that any proposal involving changes to provincial boundaries must respect the provincial assembly's resolutions and constitutional requirements.
According to Hamid Mir, the party remains committed to its position that Sindh should not be divided, while new provinces in Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa could be considered as both provincial assemblies alread passed resolutions in favor of new provinces.
The party has also advocated discussing the matter in parliament rather than allowing decisions to be made outside the political and constitutional framework.
One proposal under discussion is to seek public opinion through a referendum or parliamentary debate before proceeding with the creation of new provinces.
The PPP's position reflects the political sensitivity of the issue in Sindh, where the possibility of dividing the province has historically generated strong opposition.
However, the party's willingness to participate in discussions about administrative restructuring suggests that the debate could continue if its concerns about Sindh are addressed.
- Bilawal-Fazl contact adds another political dimension
Meanwhile, a telephone conversation between PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari and Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F) leader Maulana Fazlur Rehman has drawn attention to possible changes in political alignments.
According to a PPP statement, the two leaders discussed the country's political situation, with Bilawal condemning what he described as government actions against the JUI-F and political victimisation of the opposition.
Bilawal said the government should tolerate criticism from opposition parties and avoid measures that could weaken parliament and democratic institutions.
Political observers have interpreted the contact as a sign that the PPP is maintaining communication with opposition leaders at a time when disagreements over governance and constitutional issues are becoming more prominent.
Some analysts believe the outreach could also serve as a political signal to the government and powerful institutions that the PPP has options beyond its existing governing arrangement if its concerns are ignored.
However, neither Bilawal nor Fazlur Rehman publicly indicated that their conversation was specifically about the creation of new provinces.
The development has nevertheless raised questions about whether the PPP could increase political cooperation with opposition parties if disagreements with the government deepen.
- Could Shehbaz Sharif face pressure within his own party?
The debate also presents a political challenge for Shehbaz Sharif, who must balance the views of the PML-N leadership, the PPP and other political stakeholders.
According to Hamid Mir, the prime minister favours the creation of new provinces, while Nawaz Sharif and Maryam Nawaz have reservations.
Some political commentators believe that if Shehbaz Sharif's position is weakened or he is sidelined in the decision-making process, differences within the governing party could become more visible.
President Zardari's approach could also prove important. Political analysts believe he may prefer negotiations and political compromise rather than confrontation, while seeking assurances that the PPP's position on Sindh and its broader political interests are protected.
= Role of Imran Khan and opposition parties
The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), led by former prime minister Imran Khan, could also influence the debate.
Khawaja Asif has publicly advised Khan to support the creation of new provinces, arguing that agreement on administrative reforms could create opportunities for his return to mainstream politics.
Asif said politics was about possibilities and that political disagreements could be resolved through negotiations.
Senior journalist Hamid Mir has said Khan is reportedly open to dialogue but wants confidence-building measures before entering into a broader political understanding with the government.
These reportedly include relief for PTI leaders and the release of Khan's wife, Bushra Bibi.
Mir has also suggested that Mahmood Khan Achakzai and Allama Raja Nasir Abbas could play a role in facilitating communication with Khan and helping find a way out of the political deadlock.
The involvement of opposition leaders could become important if the government seeks a broader parliamentary agreement on constitutional changes.
- Constitutional requirements for new provinces
Creating new provinces in Pakistan would require significant constitutional and parliamentary support.
Under Article 239 of the Constitution, a constitutional amendment seeking to alter the limits of a province must be passed by a two-thirds majority of the total membership of both houses of parliament and approved by the relevant provincial assembly through a two-thirds majority of its total membership.
This means that no government can establish a new province through an executive decision alone.
The process would require negotiations among political parties, provincial representatives and parliamentarians, particularly because changes to provincial boundaries involve questions of political representation, resources, administration and provincial autonomy.
Pakistan has four provinces: Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. Demands for additional provinces have emerged over the years, particularly in southern Punjab, where supporters argue that a separate administrative unit would improve governance and address regional disparities.
There have also been proposals for changes in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, although the political and geographical considerations differ from those in Punjab.
Supporters of creating new provinces argue that Pakistan's existing administrative structure places considerable pressure on provincial governments and makes it difficult to deliver public services effectively across large and geographically diverse territories.
They say smaller provinces could improve access to government services, strengthen local representation, facilitate development planning and reduce administrative concentration in provincial capitals.
The demand for a separate province in southern Punjab, for example, has been linked to complaints about unequal development, limited political representation and the concentration of administrative authority in Lahore.
Supporters of administrative restructuring also argue that smaller administrative units could make governments more accountable to local populations.
However, critics warn that creating new provinces without addressing financial arrangements, institutional capacity and resource distribution could generate additional administrative costs and political disputes.
The distribution of water, revenues, government employees, infrastructure and natural resources would also need to be addressed in any restructuring plan.
- A potentially significant change in Pakistan's political structure
The renewed discussion about new provinces comes at a time when Pakistan is also facing political tensions, economic challenges and demands for stronger democratic institutions.
The government's ability to build consensus will depend on whether it can reconcile the positions of the PML-N, PPP, PTI and other political parties while addressing provincial concerns.
For the PPP, protecting Sindh's territorial integrity remains a central consideration. For the PML-N, internal agreement among its leadership will be important. The PTI's position could also influence the broader parliamentary debate.
The creation of new provinces could bring significant changes to Pakistan's administrative and political structure, but the process would require more than statements of support from government ministers.
A broad constitutional agreement, provincial approval and a clear framework for governance, finances and resource distribution would be essential.
Whether the current consultations lead to a formal parliamentary initiative or remain part of a wider political debate will become clearer as discussions among the country's political leadership continue.